AMERICAN IDOL - THE FINAL SEASON

Yes, it's just the way it is and nobody should feel bad about it!

Artists like passionate fans but not to the point they get upset with others because artists know only too well that musical tastes are totally subjective!  Rob and I could NOT have more different taste in music and yet we live together and have a wonderful marriage!!  Even though when he plays Frank Sinatra I want to run screaming from the house!!!!! 

Oh, and for the record - saying things to another poster like "You bash them every chance you get or you're getting tiresome" will be edited out!

Every board has rules about that - telling fellow posters how to post etc.  Hopefully, I will never have to do it as I never wanted to be an admin that did that. 

And also for the record - saying you don't care for someone's voice is NOT bashing.  "He is a butt ugly, no talent creep!" is bashing

Rob and my mother would probably have gotten along. Frank was her all time favourite!

Anyhow I wish all the kids good luck. They will all need it out there in the real world!

I will hang out in Daltons thread.  I will not comment on Mac, LaPorcha etc.

I just think it is common curtiousy to comment when asked to. FC I know you don't love Daltons voice but you could have said nice, he looked good, the entire version of HDTY just ok for me but I wish him well.  But believe me I won't ask again.

And I have said Dalton looks good, is a nice kid and I wish him well several times.

Trent vs. Blake Shelton if anyone wishes to vote! I love them both but I did vote for Trent  

http://tasteofcountry.com/trent-harmon-blake-shelton-showdown/

I have been voting for Trent.

Cool!

I don't like Blake. I'll see if I can vote from Canada.

American Idol Heart Throbs

http://theodysseyonline.com/midlothian-virginia/american-idol-heartthrobs/424004k

I have to say I agree with most of those especially #1! Aw Riley, should have gone places. America sure messed that one up!

Well no Chris and Jason but yeah they got many correct.
Con, Adam, Riley ( he was screwed getting cut. Idol blew it) of course I agree the hottest of the hot.

Agree With many but would add!
Season 1 Justin
Season 2 be Clay and Josh
Season 3 was a girls season so I will say out of the guys it would be my George
Season 4 Anthony for me all the way do not like Con
Season 5 Ace,Chris and Bucky.  I thought Taylor was great looking but he wasn't a heart throb during the season cause he was caring too much weight got better looking when he took that weight off.
Season 6 Blake and Chris
Season 7 David Archuleta, Jason, Michael Johns and David Cook.
Season 8 Kris and Adam
Season 9 Aaron and Casey James
Season 10 Scotty, Stefano
Season 11 Colton
Season 12 Don't remember the guys that well for that season which was a girls season.
Season 13 Didn't watch the season
Season 14 Nick,(Didn't watch the season but have seen Nick)
Season 15 Dalton and Mac.

Shannon    

It is in season order not hottest order.

I disagree with a lot of it.  Anyone putting Archie over Michael Johns for HOTTEST of that season is confused!!  I thought Cook was hotter than Archie also.  Archie was just a sweet, cute kid.

That Arron kid?  Sam?  Again, sweet kids - not hot. 

Stefano for sure!  Lazarro??? 

No Casey James???

This person's taste and mine do not jive.

Firecracker wrote:

It is in season order not hottest order.

I disagree with a lot of it.  Anyone putting Archie over Michael Johns for HOTTEST of that season is confused!!  I thought Cook was hotter than Archie also.  Archie was just a sweet, cute kid.

That Arron kid?  Sam?  Again, sweet kids - not hot. 

Stefano for sure!  Lazarro??? 

No Casey James???

This person's taste and mine do not jive.

I agreed with some on the list and then added on or changed some for my list.

Eta: She didn't have Stefano on her list she just said Scotty for her list. My list is above your post!

Shannon

Yes, I agree way more with your list than hers

I think her list is from a teen perspective.

No Chris, Bucky, Casey James, Bo, Michael Johns or David Cook is just crazy.

I agree!

Or Jason Castro. 

But like Angel said many on her list are right.

I agree with some. Would add others.

Some of the idol alumni are still finding pics from the finale on their cameras and posting them. Jasmine Trias posted this



Shannon

James and Scotty look very good in that picture

They all look really good!!

Firecracker wrote:

They all look really good!!

Yep!

Shannon

Yes but I forgot how tiny Elliott is.

https://scontent-lax3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xpa1/t31.0-8/13055783_10156967404755601_2686612633710765651_o.jpg

Shannon